Doctor’s Ethical Dilemma In The JKN Era (Raboan Discussion Forum)

Wednesday (23/02) the Center for Bioethics and Medical Humanities (CBMH FK-KMK) Universitas Gadjah Mada held a weekly Raboan Discussion Forum. On that occasion, the title that was raised was I Did Everything For My Patients Ethical Dilemmas of Specialist Doctors in the JKN Era. Present as speakers were dr. Sigid Kirana Lintang Bhima, Sp.FM(K), Secretary of the MKEK IDI Region of Central Java and Lecturer at the Faculty of Medicine, Diponegoro University. Meanwhile, the forum was chaired by dr. Nur Azid Mahadinata.

dr. Sigid highlighted a phenomenon that occurred to doctors in the era of the National Health Insurance (JKN) or also commonly known as BPJS. The existence of health insurance raises ethical dilemmas that are often experienced by doctors.

A doctor in carrying out his profession in providing health services has an obligation to follow three things, namely ethical legal discipline. These three things are contained in the Indonesian Doctor’s Code of Ethics (KODEKI), Laws and Regulations (UU 29 of 2004), as well as the Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) of each health facility.

In practice, as a decision-makers, doctors often experience dilemmas when faced with JKN patients. In the JKN era, doctors have a duty to consider patient funding as a factor in making decisions.

Based on the research of dr. Sigid in Semarang, this phenomenon turned out to be difficult for specialist doctors in making decisions regarding patient care. This is also coupled with the lack of socialization related to BPJS implementing regulations for specialist doctors. Often doctors feel they have to do trial and error when treating patients.

From dr. Sigid research can be concluded as an input for stakeholders, especially BPJS to improve the way of socializing the use of social insurance. Socialization needs to be carried out thoroughly and directly to doctors and patients so that there are no difficulties for all parties in the future.

 

Religion and Xenotransplantation (Raboan Discussion Forum)

Wednesday, February 16, 2022, the Raboan Discussion Forum was again held by the Center of Bioethics and Medical Humanities (CBMH FK-KMK UGM) with the title Religions and Xenotransplantation. The title was presented by the speaker Prof. Syafaatun Almirzanah Ph.D from Prof. Syafaatun Almirzanah Ph.D., Center for Religion and Sciences Sunan Kalijaga State Islamic University. Meanwhile, the moderator was Dr. Nur Azid Mahardinata from CBMH FK-KMK UGM.

Prof. Syafaatun or who is usually called by the name of Prof. Shafa raised an issue that has recently been widely discussed, namely the transplantation of a pig heart into the body of a heart failure patient named David Bennet, who is 57 years old. The male patient was reported to be in a terminal condition so xenotransplantation had to be performed. Based on developments, it is known that David Bennet has improved after surgery. Prof. Shafa added that the procedure carried out on David Bennet had been authorized by the United States Food and Drug Administration (FDA).

“It says here that if he is transplanted with a human heart his condition is too sick, so the FDA there authorized him to be given a transplant from a genetically authored pig,” said Prof. Shafa
The practice of Xenotransplantation has been done decades ago. The most famous example is Baby Fae who received a liver transplant from a primate. Baby Fae reportedly lived for 12 days after surgery.
Several ethical and social implications overshadow the development of this biotechnology. Among them is the patient’s consent which will continue to be monitored for life. Another issue is fairness and equity regarding the allocation of organs. In addition, this practice has potential in terms of social and psychological impact.

Prof. Shafa then brought the discussion to the discussion of Xenotransplantation in religion. According to Prof. Shafa, most religions can accept this technology despite the debate. The issue that is quite crucial is the process of human creation. Xenotransplantation is considered to be able to obscure the uniqueness of human identity because humans have been created by God in a form that later becomes their self-esteem. Another opinion from the Catholic Religion says that Xenotransplantation can be done but is not allowed for human brain organs and also human genitals. This is because the two organs involve self-esteem as human beings.

Another issue that is also a concern is the fear of technology making humans too late to create a Frankenstein (undead) that can attack its creator. There are fears of manipulation of human cells that could make the creation too late and harm other humans.

Modern Paradigm in Medang Mataram Era (Raboan Discussion Forum)

Wednesday, February 9, 2022, the Center for Bioethics and Medical Humanities (CBMH FKKMK UGM) again held the Raboan Discussion Forum. On that occasion, the theme raised was Modern Paradigm in the Field of Science and Technology, Government and Social Life System that Has Been Implemented in the Classical Javanese Era Medang I Bhumi Mataram. The theme was presented by the speaker: Ki Dr. Budiono Santoso Setradjaja, PhD., Sp.FK. The virtual discussion forum is led by Moderator: dr. Nur Azid Mahadinata.

Dr. Budiono thought that in recent society there were misconceptions about the quality of human technology during the Medang Mataram kingdom which had spread systematically and from generation to generation. An example is the story of the construction of a temple that was built mystically with an unexplainable logical framework. According to Dr. Budiono, this could result in the erosion of the current generation’s confidence in the abilities and capacities of their ancestors in terms of knowledge and technology. Even though the ancestors during the Medang Mataram kingdom had abilities in the fields of technology, science, and governance that were no less than the modern era. So it is very important to straighten out these myths and spread the truth about what happened to preserve and protect material and intangible relics of the Medang Mataram kingdom.

The Medang Mataram Kingdom is famous for its material heritage which can still be seen today. Among them are Borobudur Temple (Bhumi Sambara Budhara) & Prambanan Temple (Ciwagraha). The two temples have been recognized by UNESCO as World Cultural Heritage since 1991. From the construction of the Borobudur temple, three important lessons can be learned, namely the leap in the mastery of technology, consistency of policies across generations, and consistency and precision of technology.

“Medang leaders have a far-sighted vision. Approximately 70 years ago, Medang leaders decided to build a colossal architecture that could last thousands of years,” said Dr. Budiono.

Based on the research of Ir. Hadiwaratama, MSc. E revealed that the architecture of the temple was designed with the scientific principles of binary-coded mathematics so that it is always symmetrical. Binary numbers are also like those that appear in literature and batik works.

Not only building technology, during the Medang Mataram era, the people also had marine transportation technology in the form of outrigger boats. Based on the findings of Prof. Dr. Umar Anggara Jenie, Apt, Msc, the sailors’ outrigger boats were able to reach mainland Southeast Asia, Africa, and the Pacific. At that time Medang was a rich maritime and agrarian kingdom that had trading commodities of cinnamon, cardamom, rice, spices.

In the field of governance, the Medang Mataram kingdom runs a unitary state power system. This is like a democratic system originating from western countries which are now used in the modern era. In the era of Medang Mataram, various levels of government were found that were autonomous and decentralized.

During the Medang Kingdom, the concept of gender equality was also known. This can be seen from the election of female leaders such as Ratu Shima from Kalingga, Pramodhawardhani from Medang, Sri Isyana Tunggawijaya from Medang and Tribhuana Tungga Dewi who was the political architect of Majapahit.

According to Dr. Budiono, several steps need to be taken so that the conservation and protection of the Medang Mataram heritage can continue to be carried out. Among them are by conducting studies and publications on the classical Javanese Medang era, commemorating the history of the founding of the Medang Mataram kingdom on October 6, Proposing the commemoration of Archipelago Culture Day every October 6, holding the Pramodawardani & Raka I Pikatan Ballet performances, making book publications about the Characters Women of the Classical Javanese or Nusantara Era.

Consumer Behaviour in Health Sector during Pandemic (Raboan Discussion Forum)

Wednesday, February 2, 2022, the Center for Bioethics and Medical Humanities held a Raboan Discussion Forum with the theme Consumer Behavior in Health Industry. This theme was presented by Dr. Shine Pintor S. Patiro, S.T., M.M from the Faculty of Economics at the Open University. Meanwhile, the moderator was Puri Swastika GKD, S.E., M.Sc.

The Covid-19 pandemic has brought new dynamics to the Health industry players. This happens because there is a change in consumer behavior as a result of the increasing need for health goods and services. Dr. Pintor explained that during the pandemic, consumer behavior in the health industry became an issue that was widely discussed.

Consumers are customers or actors who use the goods and services offered by the company. Consumer behavior is an activity ranging from searching, choosing available alternatives, determining the final decision to buy goods or services, using or spending an item or service, to evaluating. Consumer behavior includes emotional and mental aspects because it involves the process of growing perceptions and attitudes.

Before delving deeper into consumer behavior, Dr. Pintor explained the importance of knowing the consumer market and marketing strategy. For this reason, several factors need to be considered, namely market size, changes in purchasing behavior and purchasing decisions, emphasis on market orientation, and designing an effective marketing strategy.

Dr. Pintor explained that two main factors influence Consumer Behavior, namely external factors, and internal factors. External factors are cultural and social. The factors included in the cultural factors are culture, sub-culture, and social class, while the factors included in the social factors include reference groups, family, roles, and status and roles in the buying process. Meanwhile, internal factors include personal and psychological. Factors that are included in personal factors include age, occupation, economic situation, and lifestyle. While the factors included in the psychological factors are motivation, perception, learning, belief, and attitudes.

During the COVID-19 pandemic, consumer behavior changed. According to Dr. Pintor during the covid pandemic, consumers tend to focus on things that are essential and have value. In addition, due to reduced physical activity outside the home, industry adoption towards a digital direction is very important.

“Consumers also need fast, efficient, and contact-free service,” said Dr. Pintor